Prospect Theory: A Behavioral Twist on Financial Decisions
Traditional finance assumes individuals are rational actors, always striving to maximize expected utility. Prospect theory, developed by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, challenges this assumption. It posits that people make decisions based on perceived gains and losses relative to a reference point, rather than on absolute outcomes. This deviation from rationality significantly impacts investment behavior.
At the heart of prospect theory lies the concept of loss aversion. Individuals feel the pain of a loss much more intensely than the pleasure of an equivalent gain. Studies suggest losses are psychologically twice as powerful as gains. This asymmetry influences risk-taking. When facing potential gains, investors tend to be risk-averse, preferring a smaller, certain gain over a larger, uncertain one. Conversely, when facing potential losses, they become risk-seeking, hoping to avoid the loss even if it means taking on greater risk.
Another key element is the value function. Unlike traditional utility theory, which assumes a linear relationship between wealth and utility, the value function is S-shaped. It is concave for gains, reflecting diminishing sensitivity to larger gains (the difference between $100 and $200 feels significant, but the difference between $1000 and $1100 less so). It is convex for losses, reflecting diminishing sensitivity to larger losses. The steeper slope in the loss domain illustrates the impact of loss aversion.
Probability weighting further distinguishes prospect theory. People don’t perceive probabilities accurately. They tend to overweight small probabilities and underweight large probabilities. This explains why people buy lottery tickets (overweighting the small chance of winning) and purchase insurance (overweighting the small chance of a catastrophic event). In finance, this can lead to investors clinging to losing investments longer than they should, hoping for a low-probability recovery, or selling winning investments prematurely, fearing a reversal.
The reference point is crucial. It’s the benchmark against which gains and losses are evaluated. The reference point is subjective and can be influenced by various factors, such as past performance, expectations, or even the way information is presented. For example, an investment that yields a 5% return might be viewed as a gain if the investor expected 3%, but as a loss if they expected 10%.
Prospect theory has significant implications for financial markets. It helps explain phenomena like the disposition effect (selling winners too early and holding losers too long), the endowment effect (placing a higher value on something simply because you own it), and market bubbles and crashes (driven by collective risk-seeking and loss aversion). Understanding these biases can help investors make more informed and rational decisions, mitigating the negative impacts of emotional biases on their portfolios. While not a perfect model, prospect theory provides a more realistic and nuanced understanding of how humans behave in the face of financial uncertainty compared to traditional economic models.